Coffee Journal

The Best Teas for Coffee Drinkers: 7 Cups That Hold Their Own

Yasin Sofyian Ayesh
Sketches of tea leaves, cup, and coffee beans

Roasty hojicha, malty Assam, smoky lapsang and more: the best teas for coffee drinkers, with caffeine numbers, brewing times and what to buy first.

If you love coffee, start with teas that share its best traits: roasted, malty, full-bodied and a little bitter on purpose. Hojicha, English Breakfast, Assam, lapsang souchong and masala chai fit that description. Delicate green and white teas usually don’t, and they are the reason many coffee drinkers decide they “don’t like tea.”

This guide covers what each tea tastes like, how much caffeine it has next to your usual cup, how to brew it so it doesn’t taste thin, and which one to try first.

Qahwat Al’Ard
Explore Coffee With a Sense of Place
Discover origin-driven coffee and tea, with traceable sourcing and freshly roasted beans from renowned growing regions.

TL;DR

  • Closest to coffee in flavor: hojicha, a roasted green tea with toast, nut and cocoa notes, and lapsang souchong, a smoky black tea.
  • Best strong morning cup: Assam-driven black teas and English Breakfast blends.
  • Caffeine: brewed coffee has roughly 95 to 96 mg per 8 oz cup. Black tea has about 40 to 70 mg and green tea less.
  • Brew black tea hot and for a full 5 minutes. Brew green tea cooler and shorter, or it turns bitter.
  • Skip light, grassy green teas at the start. They tend to feel like a downgrade.

Table of Contents

Why coffee drinkers often bounce off tea

Most coffee drinkers miss the same few things when they switch: body, a bitterness that feels intentional, and the roasted notes of the bean. Best Tea Bags makes this point in its guide for coffee drinkers, and it matches what we hear from customers. A pale, floral tea brewed for 90 seconds offers none of that.

The fix is to choose by flavor structure, not by tea category. Retailers that write about this topic agree on the starting point: begin with robust teas such as Assam or English Breakfast rather than delicate ones, and avoid light green teas at first because they can feel like a disappointing downgrade (Teas.co.uk).

Think of it like moving from a dark roast to a washed light roast. You don’t jump straight to the most subtle cup. You begin where the flavor is loud, then explore.

The best teas for coffee drinkers at a glance

Tea Tastes like Why coffee drinkers like it Caffeine level
Hojicha Toast, nuts, cocoa Roasted, low-acid, round Lower
Lapsang souchong Campfire smoke, dark and resinous Bold, bittersweet, memorable Moderate
English Breakfast Thick, malty, brisk The “everyday cup” feel Moderate
Assam Malty, full-bodied Strong enough to take milk like a latte Moderate to high for tea
Masala chai Spiced, creamy with milk A café-style ritual drink Moderate
Oolong (darker styles) Caramel, brown sugar Deep and complex without being grassy Moderate
Herbal infusions such as rooibos Sweet, woody, fruity Caffeine-free evening option None

The first group, hojicha and lapsang, matches coffee’s roast. The second, Assam and English Breakfast, matches its strength. Chai matches the café habit. Each section below says who it suits.

Roasted teas that taste closest to coffee

Hojicha

If you try only one tea from this list, make it hojicha. It is a Japanese green tea that is roasted, which turns the color reddish brown and swaps the grassy flavor for toast, nut and cocoa. In Best Tea Bags’ comparison, Yamamotoyama Hojicha was the closest flavor match to coffee among the teas listed, at $6.20 for 16 bags on Amazon as of July 22, 2026.

Hojicha is also one of the gentler options on caffeine, which is why people choose it for the afternoon. It brews without much fuss and rarely turns harsh.

We carry our hojicha for exactly this reader, and we also offer hojicha with mushrooms if you like the earthy, functional-café style. For more on flavor, preparation and recipes, see our hojicha guide, written in Spanish.

Lapsang souchong

Lapsang souchong is a Chinese black tea dried over smoke. If you like very dark roasts, or you drink coffee for the bitter, charred edge, this is your tea. It is not subtle. Some people love it at the first sip, and others find it too smoky, so buy a small tin first.

Best Tea Bags lists it among the picks for coffee-like roasted flavor and quotes Harney & Sons Lapsang at $11.20 for a 3 oz tin, about 32 cents per cup, as of July 22, 2026. For the story behind the smoke, read our lapsang souchong article, also in Spanish.

Tip: use a bit less leaf than you would for a regular black tea and add a splash of milk if the smoke is too strong.

Malty black teas for a strong morning cup

English Breakfast

English Breakfast is a blend, usually built on Assam and other black teas, designed to stand up to milk and a big breakfast. That makes it the easiest bridge for a drip coffee drinker: you can make it in a mug, drink it quickly, and it doesn’t ask you to learn anything.

Reviewers describe the style as dense and rustic. A May 2025 review of UK brands described Twinings English Breakfast as thick like tar, priced at £2.90 for 40 bags in the UK. Best Tea Bags, writing for US shoppers, calls Yorkshire Red thick and malty, at $16.20 for 240 bags (about 7 cents a cup) as of July 2026.

Our own English Breakfast is the one to pick if you want to buy it alongside your coffee in one order.

English Breakfast

Assam

Assam is the Indian black tea behind most breakfast blends, and drinking it straight gives you the malty backbone without the blending. Reddit’s tea community often suggests Assam tea made by the CTC method, which produces small, tight pellets that brew dark and fast (r/tea thread). That is why it feels so coffee-like in the cup: strong color, quick extraction, and body.

Who it suits: anyone who wants a big, no-fuss mug at 7 a.m. and who adds milk or a little sugar.

Spiced and complex alternatives

Masala chai

Masala chai combines black tea with spices such as cardamom, cinnamon and ginger, usually served with milk. It appeals to coffee drinkers who treat their cup as a ritual, or who order lattes. Best Tea Bags includes masala chai among the teas that suit coffee drinkers. Brew it strong and then add warm milk, and it behaves a lot like a latte.

Darker oolong

If you want something that isn’t black tea and isn’t grassy, a roasted or darker oolong is worth a try. Wirecutter’s tasting team singled out Third Culture Bakery’s Honey Bug Bite Oolong for its deep, complex flavor and caramelly brown sugar notes, which may attract coffee drinkers who want a non-black option.

Pu-erh and yerba mate

Ripe (shu) pu-erh is earthy and dark, and several guides recommend it to coffee drinkers, as does the Reddit thread above. Yerba mate is a South American herbal infusion with a bitter, grassy kick that people use as a coffee replacement. Both are acquired tastes. Try them after you are comfortable with hojicha and a malty black tea.

Caffeine-free: rooibos and herbals

If you need to cut caffeine, look at herbal infusions. They aren’t technically tea, and true tea always contains caffeine. Rooibos is the classic coffee-drinker pick because it has body and a gentle sweetness. Our Apple Cider Rooibos and Mango Treat are two flavored options for the evening cup.

How much caffeine are you giving up?

Here is the practical part, because many people switch to tea to drink less caffeine, and others are afraid it won’t wake them up.

Drink (8 oz) Typical caffeine
Brewed coffee About 95 mg (Best Tea Bags, citing USDA) or 96 mg (Mayo Clinic via Prevention)
Black tea Roughly 40 to 70 mg; 48 mg in the Mayo Clinic figure
Green tea 29 mg in the Mayo Clinic figure; 17 to 56 mg in ConsumerLab’s tests of non-decaf green teas made from about 2 grams of leaf

So a cup of black tea has roughly half the caffeine of a cup of coffee, give or take. Strong brewing, more leaf and longer steeping all push the number up, which is why ranges are wide. If you were drinking three coffees a day, you may need two or three mugs of black tea to get the same lift, and that is fine.

For context, the FDA’s commonly cited guideline is that up to 400 mg of caffeine a day is generally safe for most healthy adults. If you are pregnant, have a heart condition or take medication that interacts with caffeine, ask your doctor what limit is right for you.

Caffeine labeling on tea is also inconsistent. In the US, quantitative caffeine labeling is voluntary, so many boxes give no number. Our deeper look at the topic, Tea vs. Coffee: 247 mg of Caffeine Isn’t the Whole Story, explains why the milligram count is only part of how a drink feels, and our caffeine by tea type guide (in Spanish) goes type by type.

How much caffeine are you giving up?

How to brew tea so it tastes full

Most bad first experiences with tea are brewing mistakes. Coffee drinkers are used to precision, so use it here.

  1. Black teas and herbal infusions: Serious Eats recommends 212°F water for about 5 minutes. Use water straight off the boil and set a timer.
  2. Green teas: the same guide suggests 175°F for 1 to 3 minutes to avoid bitterness. Hojicha is a green tea, but because it is roasted, many people brew it hotter than a regular green. Start at the hotter end and adjust to taste.
  3. Use enough leaf. A weak tea is almost always too little leaf or too short a steep. A level teaspoon per 8 oz is a normal starting point.
  4. Taste at the middle of the range, then adjust. Black tea at 5 minutes is strong, and that is the point.
  5. Add milk or sweetener if you like it. You’d do the same with coffee.

Our water temperature guide for tea goes through each tea type in more detail (in Spanish). A variable-temperature kettle is a small, useful purchase if you drink a lot of tea.

What to check before you buy

  • Loose or bagged? Both work. Loose leaf usually has more flavor control, and bags are convenient at work.
  • Origin and freshness. The same traits you check on a bag of beans matter here: where it grew, how it was processed, and when it was packed.
  • Green tea quality. ConsumerLab’s testing found that catechin and caffeine levels varied by more than 240% across green tea products and that some contained lead. It advised filtering tea and not eating the leaves unless you know they are uncontaminated. That research dates from 2013, so treat it as a reason to buy from sellers that share sourcing details.
  • Price per cup. A 240-bag box at about 7 cents a cup and a small tin of specialty tea at about 32 cents a cup serve different purposes. Work out cost per serving before you compare.

Our view: tea is for coffee people too

We started as a coffee company, and we think about tea the way we think about beans: where it comes from, how it was roasted, and what that does in your cup. That is why we love hojicha for coffee drinkers. The roast is the flavor, just as in a good medium roast.

Our advice is simple. Don’t ask a coffee drinker to enjoy a tea that tastes like hot grass. Start with a roasted or malty tea, brew it properly, and let your palate widen on its own schedule. A good hojicha in the afternoon and a strong English Breakfast in the morning can sit comfortably next to your espresso.

Origin stories matter in tea as much as in coffee, and we try to tell them in every product description we write.

Yasin Sofyian Ayesh

Try tea next to your coffee order

If you already buy coffee from us, adding tea takes one more click. Browse our full tea collection for hojicha, English Breakfast and flavored options, or look at the sample pack collection if you like to taste before committing to a full size.

FAQ

What tea tastes most like coffee?

Hojicha is the usual answer. It is a roasted green tea with toast, nut and cocoa notes, and it was named the closest to coffee in one US comparison. Lapsang souchong is the other pick if you like dark, smoky flavors.

Does tea have as much caffeine as coffee?

No, not cup for cup. Brewed coffee averages around 95 mg per 8 oz, while black tea is roughly 40 to 70 mg and green tea is lower. Brew time and leaf amount change the number, so these are ranges, not guarantees.

Which tea gives the strongest morning kick?

Choose a bold black tea such as Assam or an English Breakfast blend, and steep it the full 5 minutes at 212°F. That gives you the most caffeine tea typically offers, along with a malty body that feels like coffee. Matcha and yerba mate are other options some people use.

Can I drink tea if I want to cut caffeine completely?

Only herbal infusions are caffeine-free, because all true tea (green, black, oolong, white) contains some caffeine. Rooibos is a good place to start. Hojicha is a lower-caffeine true tea if you want to reduce rather than eliminate it.

Should coffee drinkers add milk to tea?

It works well with malty black teas, English Breakfast, Assam and chai, which are built for it. Hojicha and lapsang are usually drunk plain, though a splash of milk is fine if you like it.

Sources

Yorum bırakın

Lütfen yorumların yayınlanmadan önce onaylanması gerektiğini unutmayın.